One in eight emergency room visits is for mental health. My loved one waited 36 hours for medication during a psychiatric crisis. I wanted to sue the hospital. Two years later, I’m on their patient advocacy board—and the ER now uses a mental health intake checklist I created.
Here’s what changed between “I want to sue” and “Will you join our board?”
Not anger. Not threats. Not litigation.
Conversation. Data. And leadership that actually leans into hard discussions.
If you’ve ever tried to change organizational culture—whether in healthcare, manufacturing, hospitality, or tech—you know that most change initiatives fail. Research shows poor internal communication is the leading cause of organizational change failure. But here’s the uncomfortable truth most consultants won’t tell you: The reason your culture change failed wasn’t the strategy. It was how you tried to implement it.
Let me show you what actually works.
The 36-Hour Gap That Changed Everything
When someone you love is in a mental health crisis, they can’t advocate for themselves. Their ability to communicate, make decisions, and explain their medical history is compromised by the very condition that brought them to the emergency room.
That’s why I was there. To be the voice when he couldn’t speak.
Mental health episode. Emergency room at Memorial Hermann Hospital in Cypress, Texas. My view of the situation, was the staff assumed he’d be transferred to a psychiatric facility, so they didn’t administer his medications because they were costly. But the transfer didn’t happen. I called the patient advocate. Nothing changed.
Thirty-six hours later, he still hadn’t received his medication and I had to work and escalate beyond the patient advocate to get his meds to him, which was I brought the bottles with his prescription.
I told the charge nurse this was unethical—a statement that should have triggered immediate response in any healthcare system. It didn’t.
I was furious. I wanted to sue and my friends told me I had a decent chance of prevailing. I had every right to.
My mom gave me different advice: “If you want change, write a detailed, strongly-worded letter after you get the bill for services. Not before.”
So I waited.
What Most People Do When Systems Fail Them
Let’s be honest about what happens when organizations fail us:
The Default Response:
- Threaten litigation
- Demand to speak to managers
- Escalate through formal complaints
- Post negative reviews
- Walk away and tell everyone how terrible they are
The Expected Outcome:
- Organization gets defensive
- Staff circles the wagons
- Legal department gets involved
- Everyone focuses on liability, not improvement
- Nothing actually changes for the next patient
I’ve consulted with dozens of organizations going through “culture change initiatives.” Here’s what they do wrong:
They treat change like a campaign of demands rather than a series of conversations.
They issue new policies from the top down and expect compliance.
They blame “resistant employees” when the change doesn’t stick.
Meanwhile, research has known the answer for decades.
The Research They Don’t Teach in Business School
In 1999, organizational change researcher J.D. Ford published something that should be branded on every CEO’s wall:
“Conversations are the target, medium, and product of organizational change.”
Read that again. Not plans. Not mandates. Not new policies.
Conversations.
Organizations don’t change through top-down directives. They change through ongoing dialogues that shift mental models and create shared understanding.
But it gets better. In 2020, researchers Men, Neill, and Yue proved what Ford theorized: Two-way, open, and responsive communication between managers and employees is critical for change success. Their research found that poor internal communication is the single biggest predictor of change initiative failure.
Let me translate this into founder language:
If you’re trying to change your organization by telling people what to do, you’ve already lost.
Culture changes when leadership creates space for real dialogue—and then actually listens.
What I Did Instead of Suing
When the head of patient advocacy finally called, she asked if I’d be willing to share my story with department heads.
I said yes.
I walked into that meeting with data, not anger:
- A detailed timeline of the 36-hour medication gap
- Documentation of every call and conversation
- A checklist I’d created showing what information should be gathered during mental health ER intake
- Specific examples of how the communication breakdown put my loved one at risk
Some department heads truly listened. Some made excuses and were defensive. One was a complete chowder head who clearly didn’t want to hear it.
But here’s what didn’t happen:
❌ I didn’t yell
❌ I didn’t threaten
❌ I didn’t make accusations
I showed them from my point of view what went wrong. Step by step. With evidence.
The difference?
One approach triggers organizational defenses. The other creates space for organizational learning.
They asked me to join the patient advocacy board.
The Results: Why Dialogue Works Better Than Demands
Two years later, here’s what changed at Memorial Hermann:
Result #1: The ER Mental Health Checklist is now used system-wide.
The tool I created to prevent future medication gaps is now part of their standard intake protocol for mental health patients. It ensures that even when patients can’t communicate clearly, family advocates can provide critical information about medications, psychiatric history, and treatment plans.
Result #2: They actually listen to patient feedback now.
The culture shifted from “here’s what we did wrong and why it’s not really our fault” to “here’s what we learned and here’s how we’re changing.”
Result #3: Real, measurable improvement in patient experience.
A friend recently took a loved one to that same ER for a mental health crisis. Their experience was dramatically better. The intake process worked. The communication worked. The advocacy worked.
Large organizations—hospitals, corporations, nonprofits, manufacturing companies—don’t change overnight. They change step by step.
But here’s the critical factor most people miss: Memorial Hermann changed because their CEO and leadership team actually lean into hard discussions.
Research calls this “two-way symmetrical communication.” I call it courage.
The Framework: How to Create Culture Change Through Dialogue
If you’re trying to change culture in your organization, here’s what actually works:
Step 1: Replace Anger with Data, and augment data with active listening
Don’t lead with: “This is unacceptable!” “You need to fix this immediately!” “I’m going to sue if this doesn’t change!”
Lead with: “Here’s what happened, minute by minute.” “Here’s where the breakdown occurred.” “Here’s what could have prevented this.”
Data creates space for dialogue. Anger creates defensiveness. Active listening even when it is hard and not interrupting builds empathy
Step 2: Create Space for Two-Way Communication
Real change happens when:
- Leadership asks questions, not just issues directives
- Staff can voice concerns without fear of punishment, if you have repercussions then all you will have is yes people
- Conversations go both ways (manager ↔ employee, not manager → employee)
- Feedback actually changes decisions
The research is clear: organizations that foster “symmetrical internal communication” see significantly higher rates of successful change implementation.
Ask yourself: When was the last time your leadership team truly listened to front-line staff about a major change initiative?
Step 3: Show What’s Possible, Don’t Just Criticize What’s Wrong
I didn’t just complain about the medication gap. I brought a solution: the ER Mental Health Checklist.
I showed them exactly what information should be gathered during intake to prevent future gaps.
It’s easy to criticize. It’s harder to build.
If you want to change culture, offer to be part of the solution.
Step 4: Accept That Some People Won’t Get It (And That’s Okay)
Remember: some department heads listened. Some made excuses. One was a chowder head.
Culture change doesn’t require unanimous buy-in. It requires enough people in positions of influence who are willing to learn.
The question isn’t “How do I get everyone on board?” The question is “Do I have enough leaders who will champion this conversation?”
Step 5: Measure What Matters
How do you know culture is changing?
Not through engagement surveys or mission statement posters.
You know it’s working when:
- Processes actually change (the checklist gets adopted)
- Communication patterns shift (staff feel heard)
- Outcomes improve (patients have better experiences)
Culture change is measured in behaviors and results, not in PowerPoint decks about “our values.”
Beyond Healthcare: Where Else This Works
You might be thinking: “Brandon, this is about a hospital. I run a manufacturing company / SaaS startup / restaurant chain. How does this apply to me?”
Here’s how:
Manufacturing Floor Culture
The Old Way: Management mandates new safety protocols. Workers see it as “another thing corporate made up.” Compliance is low. Accidents keep happening.
The Dialogue Approach: Floor managers ask workers: “Show me where the current process puts you at risk.” Workers demonstrate the gaps. Together, they design protocols that actually work. Adoption is high because workers co-created the solution.
The Pattern: Conversations surface reality. Mandates create resistance.
Restaurant Operations
The Old Way: Corporate rolls out new POS system. Staff aren’t trained properly. Service slows down. Customer complaints spike. Corporate blames “resistant staff.”
The Dialogue Approach: Pilot the system with one location. Ask staff: “What’s working? What’s breaking?” Iterate based on feedback. Roll out refined version with champions from the pilot leading training.
The Pattern: Two-way communication surfaces problems before they become failures.
Tech Company Remote Culture
The Old Way: CEO announces “we’re all remote now” with no input. Managers don’t know how to lead remotely. Productivity drops. Trust erodes.
The Dialogue Approach: Leadership asks teams: “What do you need to work effectively from home?” Remote work policy is co-created based on actual needs, not assumptions.
The Pattern: Shared ownership creates shared commitment.
See the pattern?
Culture doesn’t change when leaders tell people what to do.
Culture changes when leaders create conversations that shift how people think and work.
The Hard Truth About Leadership and Culture Change
Here’s what I learned sitting on that patient advocacy board:
Leadership determines whether organizational learning is possible.
If your CEO, department heads, and managers don’t lean into hard conversations—if they defend, deflect, or dismiss feedback—culture can’t change. Period.
It doesn’t matter how good your strategy is.
It doesn’t matter how clear your vision is.
It doesn’t matter how much money you throw at consultants.
If leadership won’t engage in real dialogue, you’re just rearranging deck chairs.
Memorial Hermann’s CEO and leadership team did something rare: they created psychological safety for difficult conversations. They asked a patient’s family member to tell them where they failed. They listened. They changed.
That’s courage.
Most executives don’t have it.
They say they want feedback, but what they really want is validation. They say they value transparency, but they punish people who point out problems. They say culture is their priority, but their calendars show they never actually talk to front-line staff.
Ask yourself:
- When’s the last time you asked for feedback on something you personally could improve?
- Do your employees feel safe disagreeing with you?
- Have you ever changed a decision based on staff input?
- Would someone three levels below you tell you the truth?
If you answered “I don’t know” or “probably not” to any of these, your culture change initiative is doomed—no matter how good the strategy looks on paper.
The Uncomfortable Question You Need to Answer
Alright, let’s talk about you.
If you’re a founder, executive, or leader trying to change culture in your organization, here’s the question you need to answer honestly:
Are you trying to change culture through conversations, or through mandates disguised as conversations?
You know the difference.
Conversations:
- Start with genuine curiosity
- Allow for disagreement
- Can change the leader’s mind
- Lead to co-created solutions
- Result in shared ownership
Mandates disguised as conversations:
- Start with a predetermined outcome
- Invite “feedback” but don’t actually use it
- Make people feel heard without changing anything
- Lead to compliance (if you’re lucky) or quiet resistance (more likely)
- Result in leaders wondering why “no one wants to change”
Most executives think they’re having conversations when they’re really just broadcasting mandates with a friendly tone.
The research is unambiguous: that doesn’t work.
What You Should Do Next
If you’re serious about changing culture in your organization, here’s what I want you to do:
1. Identify One Area Where You’ve Been Broadcasting Instead of Dialoguing
Where have you been telling people what to do when you should have been asking them what’s not working?
Maybe it’s:
- A new process that isn’t getting adopted
- A quality issue that keeps recurring
- A turnover problem in a specific department
- A customer complaint pattern that won’t go away
Pick one. Write it down.
2. Create Space for Real Dialogue
Schedule a conversation where the only agenda is listening.
Not “listening so you can respond.”
Not “listening so you can explain why they’re wrong.”
Actual listening.
Ask:
- “What’s not working from your perspective?”
- “What would you change if you could?”
- “What am I missing?”
Then shut up and take notes.
3. Act on What You Hear
This is where most leaders fail.
They listen. They nod. They thank people for the feedback.
Then they do exactly what they were going to do anyway.
That’s not dialogue. That’s theater.
If you’re not willing to change something based on what you hear, don’t ask for input in the first place. It’s worse than not asking at all.
4. Report Back
Close the loop. Tell people what you heard and what you’re changing as a result.
Even if you can’t implement everything, explain why. Transparency builds trust.
“We heard that X is a problem. Here’s what we’re doing about it. We also heard Y, but we can’t address that right now because [real reason]. We’ll revisit it in [specific timeframe].”
5. Repeat
Culture change isn’t a project. It’s a practice.
Organizations that successfully change culture don’t do it through one big initiative. They do it through hundreds of small conversations that shift thinking and behavior over time.
One meeting won’t change culture. But one meeting a week for a year will.
The Tools: What Actually Helps
If you’re wondering “what does this look like in practice?”, here are the tools that work:
For Healthcare Organizations
The ER Mental Health Checklist I created for Memorial Hermann is available for free. It helps emergency departments gather critical information from family advocates when mental health patients can’t communicate clearly.
Download it. Use it. Adapt it for your facility.
Because one in eight ER visits is for mental health, and most hospitals still don’t have proper intake protocols.
Download the ER Mental Health Checklist
For Any Organization
The Culture Change Conversation Framework:
- Set the context: “We’re here to understand what’s not working.”
- Ask open questions: “Walk me through what happens when…”
- Probe for specifics: “Can you give me an example?”
- Validate without defending: “I hear you. That sounds frustrating.”
- Identify patterns: “It sounds like the core issue is…”
- Co-create solutions: “What would make this better?”
- Commit to action: “Here’s what we’re going to try…”
- Close the loop: “Here’s what happened after our last conversation…”
It’s simple. It’s not easy.
Most leaders can’t make it past step 4 without getting defensive.
The Bottom Line
You cannot yell your way to culture change.
You cannot mandate your way to culture change.
You cannot even strategize your way to culture change.
Culture changes through conversations.
Conversations between leaders and staff.
Conversations that surface uncomfortable truths.
Conversations where both parties are willing to change their minds.
Conversations backed by data, not just emotion.
Conversations that lead to action, not just acknowledgment.
The research proves it. My experience at Memorial Hermann proves it.
If you’re a founder, executive, or leader struggling to change culture in your organization, stop asking “What’s wrong with my people?” and start asking “What conversation am I avoiding?”
Because the culture you have is the culture your communication patterns created.
Want a different culture? Start different conversations.
Resources
Crisis Support (If You Need Advocacy Help)
- 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline – Call or text 988
- Crisis Text Line – Text HOME to 741741
- SAMHSA National Helpline – 1-800-662-4357
For Healthcare Leaders
- Free ER Mental Health Checklist – Download at gracchuspartners.com
- Patient Advocate Training Resources – Available on request
Research Citations
- Ford, J.D. (1999). “Organizational Change as Shifting Conversations.” Journal of Organizational Change Management.
- Men, L.R., Neill, M., & Yue, C.A. (2020). “Examining the Effects of Symmetrical Internal Communication and Employee Engagement on Organizational Change Outcomes.” Public Relations Journal, 13(4).
- Full reference list available at gracchuspartners.com/culture-change-research
If you’re trying to change culture in your organization and getting resistance, let’s talk.
Connect: gracchuspartners.com
Drop a comment: What conversation are you avoiding in your organization right now?
This post is based on actual events. Some details have been changed to protect patient privacy. The research cited is peer-reviewed and publicly available. The ER Mental Health Checklist was created through lived experience and consultation with healthcare professionals.
Share This
Know a leader struggling with culture change? Send them this post.
Because most organizations are trying to mandate change when they should be creating conversations.
And the research proves which one works.
[Tweet this] [Share on LinkedIn] [Email this]
Want more founder-to-founder insights?
Subscribe to the SMB Growth Unlimited podcast where we talk about what actually works in small business growth—no guru speak, no fluff, just patterns that create results.
